Snowball vs highest rate first, on real numbers
Both orders pay every minimum and send the money left over to one debt at a time. Smallest balance first (the "snowball") picks the smallest balance; highest rate first (the "avalanche") picks the debt charging the most interest that month. How far apart they end up depends entirely on the numbers, so here are two lists worked out to the cent.
Three debts, $250 extra a month
Starting January 2027, with the same $709.50 going in every month (the first month's minimums plus $250):
- Store card: $900.00 at 19.99%, minimum 3% (at least $35.00).
- Visa: $5,200.00 at 27.99%, minimum 1% plus interest (at least $40.00).
- Personal loan: $7,500.00 at 11.5%, $250.00 a month.
Smallest balance first sends the extra to the store card; highest rate first sends it to the Visa.
| Debt | Smallest balance first | Interest | Highest rate first | Interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Store card | April 2027 | $32.55 | April 2028 | $193.78 |
| Visa | May 2028 | $1,233.89 | March 2028 | $996.16 |
| Personal loan | November 2028 | $1,097.71 | November 2028 | $1,092.59 |
| Debt-free | November 2028 | $2,364.15 | November 2028 | $2,282.53 |
Both finish in November 2028. Highest rate first costs $81.62 less interest over the 23 months. Smallest balance first has the store card gone in April 2027 instead of April 2028, one fewer bill for 12 months. On minimums only the same three debts take until March 2043 and cost $11,674.39, so either order saves far more than the gap between them ($9,310.24 and $9,391.86 against minimums only).
Add a 0% card and highest rate first can cost more
Highest rate first looks at the rate each debt charges this month. A card at 0% is at the bottom of that list until its intro rate ends, so it gets nothing extra while the 0% lasts. The planner's made-up example, from January 2027 with $200 extra a month:
- Store card: $3,600.00, 0% until October 14, 2027, then 27.99%, minimum 3% (at least $35.00).
- Visa: $2,400.00 at 24.49%, minimum 1% plus interest (at least $40.00).
- Car loan: $9,800.00 at 7.9%, $310.00 a month.
| Order | Store card owed when 0% ends | Store card paid off | Store card interest | Debt-free | Total interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smallest balance first | $2,449.49 | June 2028 | $235.08 | February 2029 | $1,531.71 |
| Highest rate first | $2,654.73 | June 2028 | $276.65 | February 2029 | $1,563.84 |
| My order: store card, Visa, car | $487.18 | December 2027 | $15.64 | February 2029 | $1,752.19 |
Here smallest balance first (the Visa first, then the store card) costs $32.13 less than highest rate first. Putting the store card first clears most of it while it is still at 0%, but the Visa's 24.49% runs longer, so that order costs the most of the three. Which of these matters more is a judgement about your own month; the planner shows all of them side by side and doesn't pick one.
How the planner keeps the comparison fair
- Every order gets the same money each month: the first month's minimums plus the extra (or that month's own extra). When a minimum shrinks or a debt is paid off, the difference goes to the next debt in the order, so no order pays less per month than another.
- Smallest balance first is fixed from the balances at the start (equal balances: the higher APR first). Highest rate first is re-sorted every month by the rate charged that month (equal rates: the smaller balance now).
- Interest each month = balance × APR ÷ 12, rounded to the cent, added before the payment. It is the same arithmetic as the payoff plan in Paid Up, checked against the same independent calculation.