Why briefs get bounced: the formatting rules courts enforce, in their own words
A brief that misses a typeface, spacing or length rule can come back with a deficiency notice, be struck, or simply not be filed until it is fixed, usually with a short deadline. Here is what the courts themselves say they do, and the handful of rules that catch people.
The rules that catch people
- Footnotes smaller than the body. Word's Footnote Text style is 10 pt. FRAP's 14-point rule has no footnote exception, and most circuits and states that allow smaller footnotes still set a floor (12 pt in Texas and the Fifth Circuit, 11 pt in the Seventh).
- The wrong word count. The certificate must give the number of words in the parts that count. Counting the whole file (cover, tables, signature block, certificates) overstates it; selecting only the argument understates it. Headings, footnotes and citations count.
- A sans-serif or unnamed typeface. FRAP asks for a serif face for the body; the Supreme Court names the Century family; Florida names Arial or Bookman Old Style, nothing else.
- Spacing squeezed to fit. "Exactly 24 pt" at 14 pt type is not double spacing. Block quotes and headings may be single-spaced; the argument may not.
- Margins and paper. A header or footer in the one-inch margin, A4 paper from an overseas template, a table that runs into the margin.
- The wrong court's numbers. FRAP's 13,000 words is 14,000 in the Second, Seventh, Ninth and Federal Circuits, 15,000 in Texas courts of appeals, 13,000 in Florida.
Check a brief in 30 seconds the file stays in your browser
FRAP's baseline
“A proportionally spaced face must be 14-point or larger.” FRAP 32(a)(5)
“The text must be double-spaced, but quotations more than two lines long may be indented and single-spaced. Headings and footnotes may be single-spaced.” FRAP 32(a)(4)
What each court says it does with a brief that does not comply
Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure
“The clerk must not refuse to accept for filing any paper presented for that purpose solely because it is not presented in proper form as required by these rules or by any local rule or practice.” FRAP
U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
“the Clerk's Office has compiled a list of common, but easily avoidable, errors that often delay the processing of cases and may result in the striking or returning for correction of submitted documents.” First Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
“A brief must be concise, logically arranged with proper headings, and free of irrelevant matter. The court may disregard a brief that does not comply with this rule.” Second Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
“If a motion, brief, or appendix submitted for filing does not comply with FRAP 27 - 32 or 3d Cir. L.A.R. 27.0 - 32.0, the clerk will file the document, but notify the party of the need to promptly correct the deficiency. … the court may, in its discretion, impose sanctions as it may deem appropriate, including but not limited to the dismissal of the appeal, striking of the document, imposition of costs or disciplinary sanctions upon counsel.” Third Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
“If briefs, appendices, or other papers are illegible or are not in the form required by the federal rules or by this Court's local rules or standards when filed, counsel will be required to file corrected copies of the document.” Fourth Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
“If all copies of briefs and record excerpts do not conform to 5TH CIR. R. 28 and 30 and all provisions of FED. R. APP. P. 32, the clerk will file the briefs and record excerpts, but is authorized to return all nonconforming copies. An extension of 10 days is allowed for resubmission in a conforming format. The court may strike briefs and record excerpts if the party fails to submit conforming briefs or record excerpts within 14 days.” Fifth Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
“The Clerk's Office retains the responsibility for manually reviewing briefs and issuing any necessary deficiency notices, as the program doesn't identify all potential issues.” Sixth Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
“If the brief does not comply with the rules, the clerk will notify the filer that the brief is defective and will allow the filer 5 days to submit a brief which complies with the rules.” Eighth Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
“Briefs not complying with FRAP and these rules may be stricken by the Court. … If a brief that exceeds the usual length limits is submitted by a party or parties ineligible for relief under Rule 32-2(b), the Clerk will reject the brief if it is not accompanied by a motion under Rule 32-2(a).” Ninth Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
“The court may reject or require recomposition of a brief for failure to comply. … unless each copy of the brief, in the judgment of the clerk, conforms to this rule and to provisions of FRAP 32(a), the clerk may conditionally file the brief, subject to the requirement that the party file in the office of the clerk a complete set of replacement briefs which comply with FRAP and circuit rules within 14 days of issuance of notice by the clerk that the briefs have been conditionally filed.” Eleventh Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
“If the court receives any submission that does not conform substantially to the requirements of the FRAP or these rules, the clerk will promptly notify the person making the submission and direct that person to cure the defect or submit an appropriate motion.” D.C. Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
“The clerk of court may require the filing of a corrected copy of any submission that fails to comply with the court’s rules or the Electronic Filing Procedures. If a party fails to file a timely corrected copy in response to a notice requiring correction from the clerk of court, the clerk of court may strike the non- … compliant document from the docket.” Federal Circuit
Supreme Court of the United States
“If the Clerk determines that a petition submitted timely and in good faith is in a form that does not comply with this Rule or with Rule 33 or Rule 34, the Clerk will return it with a letter indicating the deficiency. A corrected petition submitted in accordance with Rule 29.2 no more than 60 days after the date of the Clerk’s letter will be deemed timely.” Supreme Court
California Courts of Appeal and Supreme Court of California
“If a brief does not comply with this rule: … (1) The reviewing court clerk may decline to file it, but must mark it "received but not filed" and return it to the party; or … (2) If the brief is filed, the reviewing court may, on its own or a party's motion, with or without notice: … (A) Order the brief returned for corrections and refiling within a specified time; … (B) Strike the brief with leave to file a new brief within a specified time; or” California appellate courts
California superior courts (trial court papers)
“The clerk of the court must not accept for filing or file any papers that do not comply with the rules in this chapter, except the clerk must not reject a paper for filing solely on the ground that:” California trial courts
Texas appellate courts (Supreme Court of Texas, Court of Criminal Appeals, courts of appeals)
“(k) Nonconforming Documents. If a document fails to conform with these rules, the court may strike the document or identify the error and permit the party to resubmit the document in a conforming format by a specified deadline.” Texas appellate courts
Florida appellate courts (Supreme Court of Florida and district courts of appeal)
“After 10 days' notice, on its own motion, the court may impose sanctions for any violation of these rules, or for the filing of any proceeding, motion, brief, or other document that is frivolous or in bad faith. Such sanctions may include reprimand, contempt, striking of briefs or pleadings, dismissal of proceedings, costs, attorneys' fees, or other sanctions.” Florida appellate courts
New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division (all four Departments) and New York Court of Appeals
“(g) Rejection for Noncompliance. The clerk may reject any submission that does not comply with this Part, is incomplete, is untimely, is not legible, or fails to comply with any applicable statute, rule or order. The court may waive compliance by any party with any provision of this Part.” New York Appellate Division
Illinois Supreme Court and Appellate Court
“If after reasonable notice and an opportunity to respond, a party or an attorney for a party or parties is determined to have wilfully failed to comply with the appeal rules, appropriate sanctions may be imposed upon such a party or attorney for the failure to comply with these rules. … or that any portion of a party's brief relating to that issue be stricken.” Illinois reviewing courts
Washington Supreme Court and Court of Appeals
“If a party submits a brief that fails to comply with the requirements of Title 10 and RAP 18.17, the appellate court, on its own initiative or on the motion of a party, may (1) order the brief returned for correction or replacement within a specified time, (2) order the brief stricken from the files with leave to file a new brief within a specified time, or (3) accept the brief. The appellate court will ordinarily impose sanctions on a party or counsel for a party who files a brief that fails to comply with these rules.” Washington appellate courts
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division
“If an appendix or brief does not substantially conform to these rules or is so inadequate that justice cannot be done without the court's independent examination of the record or research of the law, the court may order the same suppressed and direct the filing, within a fixed time, of a new appendix or brief, and it may withhold or impose costs or order payment by the offending attorney or party of costs in such amount as the circumstances require.” New Jersey Appellate Division
Pennsylvania appellate courts (Supreme Court, Superior Court, Commonwealth Court)
“Briefs and reproduced records shall conform in all material respects with the requirements of these rules as nearly as the circumstances of the particular case will admit, otherwise they may be suppressed, and, if the defects are in the brief or reproduced record of the appellant and are substantial, the appeal or other matter may be quashed or dismissed.” Pennsylvania appellate courts
Ohio courts of appeals and Supreme Court of Ohio
“(F) Failure to comply Documents that fail to comply with the requirements of this rule may be stricken by the Supreme Court.” Ohio appellate courts
Court of Appeals of Georgia and Supreme Court of Georgia
“(4) Noncompliance. Any documents that do not comply with the Court rules may be returned to counsel with notice of the defect of the pleading, and/or counsel may be ordered to redact and recast them.” Georgia appellate courts
Michigan Court of Appeals and Michigan Supreme Court
“(I) Nonconforming Briefs. If, on its own initiative or on a party's motion, the court concludes that a brief does not substantially comply with the requirements in this rule, the court may order the party who filed the brief to file a supplemental brief within a specified time correcting the deficiencies, or it may strike the nonconforming brief.” Michigan appellate courts
North Carolina appellate courts (Supreme Court of North Carolina and North Carolina Court of Appeals)
“A court of the appellate division may, on its own initiative or motion of a party, impose a sanction against a party or attorney or both when the court determines that such party or … attorney or both substantially failed to comply with these rules, including failure to pay any filing or printing fees or costs when due. The court may impose sanctions of the type and in the manner prescribed by Rule 34 for frivolous appeals.” North Carolina appellate courts
Massachusetts appellate courts (Supreme Judicial Court and Appeals Court)
“Briefs, appendices, or applications for or responses to direct or further appellate review not in substantial compliance with these rules shall not be docketed unless the appellate court or a single justice shall otherwise order.” Massachusetts appellate courts
Arizona appellate courts (Arizona Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, civil appeals)
“An appellate court also may impose sanctions on an attorney or a party for a violation of these Rules. An appellate court may impose sanctions that are appropriate in the circumstances of the case, and to discourage similar conduct in the future. Sanctions may include contempt, dismissal, or withholding or imposing costs or attorneys' fees.” Arizona appellate courts
Virginia appellate courts (Supreme Court of Virginia and Court of Appeals of Virginia)
“No appeal will be dismissed for failure to comply with the provisions of this Rule; the clerk of this Court may, however, require that a document be redone in compliance with this Rule. Failure to comply after notice of noncompliance, however, may result in the dismissal of the case. … No appeal will be dismissed for failure to comply with the provisions of this Rule; however, the clerk of this Court may require that a document be redone in compliance with this Rule. However, failure to comply after notice of noncompliance may result in the dismissal of the case.” Virginia appellate courts
Colorado appellate courts (Colorado Supreme Court and Colorado Court of Appeals)
“(g) Non-Compliant Documents. If the clerk determines that a brief or other document does not comply with the Colorado Appellate Rules or is not sufficiently legible, the clerk may accept the document for filing but may require that a conforming document be filed. … I acknowledge that my brief may be stricken if it fails to comply with any of the requirements of C.A.R. 28 or 28.1, and C.A.R. 32.” Colorado appellate courts
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (motion papers)
“Failure by counsel or a party to comply with any duly promulgated local rule or any Federal Rule may be a ground for imposition of any authorized sanction.” N.D. Cal.
U.S. District Court for the Central District of California (motion papers and briefs)
“The presentation to the Court of frivolous motions or opposition to motions (or the failure to comply fully with this rule) subjects the offender at the discretion of the Court to the sanctions of L.R. 83-7. … The violation of or failure to conform to any of these Local Rules may subject the offending party or counsel to:” C.D. Cal.
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (motions and briefs)
“(g) Documents Not Complying May be Stricken. Any document that does not comply with this rule shall be filed subject to being stricken by the court. … Any brief or objection that does not comply with this rule shall be filed subject to being stricken by the court.” N.D. Ill.
Quoted from each court's rules, read November 8, 2026. Brief Preflight compares measurements with the rules as written; it cannot know a local standing order, a judge's own requirements, or whether a clerk will accept a borderline brief.
About this tool, privacy and licences
Brief Preflight is a free tool by Tomorrowish. Not legal advice and not an official compliance check. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any court; court names are used only to say whose published rules are quoted. It measures a file and sets the numbers beside the rule as written: the clerk and the court apply the rules, and local orders, standing orders, case-management orders and the judge can change them. Rules change: each page says when they were read. It never edits or writes your brief.
Privacy: your PDF or Word file is read inside this browser tab and never uploaded; the check page makes no requests to any other site (its security policy allows only tomorrowish.dev itself). The site is hosted on Cloudflare, which counts page views with Cloudflare Web Analytics (no cookies) on the rule and guide pages; on the check page its security policy blocks even that. The rule and guide pages add one to an anonymous view counter on Tomorrowish's own small server (programfold.tomorrowish.dev): which page was opened, nothing else. Your last court and document choice stays in this browser. Contact: hello@tomorrowish.dev. Privacy details · Licences.