Price cut vs 2-1 buydown vs points: one $12,000 concession, three ways
A made-up but typical case, worked out with the same arithmetic as Offer Compare. Change any number there; this page is the sample it opens with.
Arithmetic under your inputs. Not advice, not a quote. The comparison never recommends an offer.
The setup
- A $450,000 house, 20% down, a 30-year conventional loan at 7.00%, $9,000 of closing costs, 1.2% property tax reassessed at the price paid, $150 a month insurance.
- The seller will give up about $12,000. Three ways to take it:
- Price cut $12k: the price drops to $438,000, so the loan is $350,400.
- 2-1 buydown + credit: a seller-paid 2-1 temporary buydown (pay as if the rate were 5% in year 1 and 6% in year 2), which costs the seller $8,390.88, plus a $3,600 credit toward closing costs.
- 3 points to 6.25%: the seller pays 3 discount points ($10,800) that bring the rate to 6.25% for the life of the loan, plus a $1,200 credit.
Kept 7 years
| Line | Price cut $12k | 2-1 buydown + credit | 3 points to 6.25% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash to close | $96,600 | $95,400 | $97,800 |
| First month’s payment | $2,919.22 | $2,532.56 | $2,816.58 |
| Paid over 7 years | $341,814 | $338,597 | $334,393 |
| Still owed at the end | $319,381 | $328,131 | $324,121 |
| Total cost | $661,195 | $666,727 | $658,514 |
Over 7 years 3 points to 6.25% has the lowest total cost under these inputs. The buydown has the lowest payments for two years ($2,532.56 in month 1), then the loan's real 7% payment applies for the rest. A price cut lowers what you owe from day one; points lower the rate for as long as you keep the loan.
Kept 3 years, or 15
3 years:
| Line | Price cut $12k | 2-1 buydown + credit | 3 points to 6.25% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash to close | $96,600 | $95,400 | $97,800 |
| First month’s payment | $2,919.22 | $2,532.56 | $2,816.58 |
| Paid over 3 years | $201,692 | $194,832 | $199,197 |
| Still owed at the end | $338,931 | $348,217 | $346,513 |
| Total cost | $540,623 | $543,049 | $545,710 |
15 years:
| Line | Price cut $12k | 2-1 buydown + credit | 3 points to 6.25% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash to close | $96,600 | $95,400 | $97,800 |
| First month’s payment | $2,919.22 | $2,532.56 | $2,816.58 |
| Paid over 15 years | $622,060 | $626,125 | $604,784 |
| Still owed at the end | $259,362 | $266,468 | $258,517 |
| Total cost | $881,422 | $892,593 | $863,302 |
Lowest total cost: Price cut $12k at 3 years, 3 points to 6.25% at 15 years.
Break-even months
- Price cut $12k vs 3 points to 6.25%: the order flips in month 68 (5 years 8 months).
- 2-1 buydown + credit vs 3 points to 6.25%: the order flips in month 48 (4 years).
- Price cut $12k vs 2-1 buydown + credit: no crossing in 30 years; the price cut stays lower.
Why "total cost" counts what you still owe
Comparing only payments flatters any offer that leaves a bigger loan behind. When you sell or refinance you pay the balance off, so it belongs in the cost. Total cost here = cash to close + every monthly payment + the balance still owed at the end (minus any unused buydown money that goes to the payoff). The house sells for the same price whichever offer you took, so it cancels out.
What changes the answer
- How long you keep the loan. Refinancing counts as the end: a price cut keeps helping after a refinance through the smaller balance, while points and a buydown stop helping that day (unused buydown money goes to the payoff when the agreement allows it).
- What your cash could earn. Set it above 0% in the tool and money paid earlier counts for more.
- Whether your county reassesses at the sale price (a price cut then also cuts the tax).
- What your lender actually charges per point and whether the seller-paid total fits the program's limit (Fannie Mae 3% / 6% / 9% by down payment, FHA 6%, VA 4%).