Offer Compare
Put up to four offers on the same house side by side: price cut, buydown, points, credit, ARM or an assumed loan. See what each costs over the years you will keep it.
- Free
- Nothing leaves your browser
- Counts the balance you still owe
Arithmetic under your inputs. Not advice, not a quote. The comparison never recommends an offer.
The house and how long you keep it
Selling at the end costs the same whichever offer you took, so it is left out. A refinance counts as "the end" too: the balance still owed is what you would pay off. The conforming limit is $832,750 for one unit in most of the US in 2026 (higher in high-cost counties); it sets FHA's MIP bracket and the jumbo warning.
The offers
Two to four offers on the same house. Change only what differs.
What each offer costs over your hold
Total cost = cash to close + every monthly payment (principal, interest, mortgage insurance, tax, insurance, HOA) + what you still owe on every loan at the end, minus any unused buydown money that goes to the payoff. With a return on cash above 0%, money paid earlier counts for more. Lower is cheaper under your inputs.
Break-even between each pair
The first month the order flips: the offer that is cheaper for a very short stay stops being cheaper. An ARM can cross more than once; the chart shows the rest.
Month by month
Each line is the total cost if you sold (or refinanced) in that month. Move along the chart to read any month.
Year by year
How the numbers work
- Payments: standard amortization, interest rounded to the cent each month; the last payment clears the loan exactly.
- Temporary buydowns (1-0, 2-1, 3-2-1): in each buydown year you pay what the loan would cost at the lower rate; the seller's money in a buydown account pays the rest. The seller's cost is the sum of those monthly gaps (a 2-1 on $400,000 at 7% costs the seller $9,323.16). The loan itself never changes, so the balance you owe is the same as without the buydown. If you sell early, unused money can go to the payoff (a tick box; Fannie Mae allows it when the buydown agreement says so).
- Points: 1 point = 1% of the loan, paid at closing by you or by the seller. The break-even here counts the lower balance a lower rate leaves too, so it usually comes sooner than the "points รท monthly saving" rule of thumb.
- Price cut: a smaller loan and payment, smaller FHA or PMI charges, and a lower tax bill when your county reassesses at the sale price. It can also move you under 80% loan-to-value, which ends PMI.
- Assuming the seller's FHA or VA loan: you take over their balance, rate and remaining months. The gap between the price and that balance is paid in cash, and any rest becomes a second loan at its own rate. FHA assumptions keep the loan's existing MIP; VA assumptions charge a 0.5% funding fee, and the seller's VA entitlement stays with the loan unless you are a veteran who substitutes yours. FHA's assumption processing fee is capped at $1,800.
- ARMs: the start rate holds for the fixed period, then each reset moves toward the target by at most the cap (first change cap, then the later cap), never above start + lifetime cap or below the margin. The payment is recalculated at every change. Pick the worst case, index + margin, or your own path of rates.
- FHA mortgage insurance: upfront MIP of 1.75% added to the loan; annual MIP from HUD's 2023 table (50 or 55 bps for most loans, 11 years with 10% or more down, otherwise the life of the loan), worked out each year the way HUD's own example does.
- Conventional PMI: only above 80% loan-to-value, at the rate you enter, until the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original value (or 80% if you ask the lender) and never past the halfway point of the term (Homeowners Protection Act).
- Seller-paid limits: you get a warning when the seller pays more than the program allows: Fannie Mae 3% of the price with under 10% down, 6% with 10 to 25% down, 9% with 25% or more down; FHA 6%; VA 4% of concessions (normal closing costs and points are outside VA's 4%). A seller credit above your closing costs is not usable here.
What it leaves out
- Only the fees you enter. No escrow cushions, prepaid interest, appreciation, tax deductions or selling costs (those are the same whichever offer you take).
- No live rates or quotes: every rate, PMI percent and fee is yours. Your lender's Loan Estimate is the real number.
- Buydowns on ARMs, interest-only, balloon, extra payments and biweekly plans are not modelled. Property tax reassessment is one switch; your county's rules may differ.