Screenshots of texts for court: when to use the backup instead
Screenshots are the usual way people bring texts to a hearing, and the usual thing the other side attacks: which number sent this, when, what came before and after, and is anything cut out? For texts and iMessages the phone itself holds better evidence, and it can be printed without a screenshot in sight.
What a screenshot leaves out
- The number. The bubble shows the name saved in your contacts, which you typed yourself, not the phone number or email the message came from.
- The times. Messages shows a time only now and then; one screenshot can cover hours or days with no time on most messages. A screenshot file has no capture time inside it either: the PNG an iPhone or Mac saves usually records only that it is a screenshot.
- Context. A run of screenshots can skip messages, and cropping or markup is hard to rule out from a picture alone.
- Reactions, edits and unsent messages are shown loosely or not at all.
Use the backup when you can
The messages database in an iPhone backup, or an Android SMS Backup & Restore file, has every message with its exact time, the number or address of each person, delivered and read times, reactions and edits. Court Copy prints one conversation from it as a page-numbered PDF with the source file's SHA-256, in your browser:
- iPhone texts from a backup on a Windows PC · iMessage to PDF without a Mac · encrypted or unencrypted backup?
- Android texts from an SMS Backup & Restore file
- WhatsApp, Telegram, Discord and Messenger / Instagram exports
When a screenshot is all there is
Some things have no export: a social media post or story, a message in an app with no export, a disappearing message, a web page that has since changed, a message already deleted from the phone. Then a screenshot is the record, and a few habits help:
- Take it on the device that received the message, with the status bar (time, date where shown) in the picture.
- Tap the person's name first and screenshot the screen that shows their number or username too.
- Scroll a little at a time so each screenshot overlaps the one before; no gaps, no cropping, no markup on the originals.
- For a post, include the account name and the post's date; screenshot the URL too if it is a web page.
- Keep the original screenshot files untouched in their own folder. Mark up copies, never the originals.
Then print them with Court Copy's photos, screenshots and scans input: one screenshot per page, numbered as exhibits, each with its file name, SHA-256 and pixel size, and the plain statement "no capture time is stored in the file" where that is the case. The file's own modified date is printed as a file date, not a capture time. You can caption each one ("Facebook post by the landlord, seen on 3 March") and black out what must not be shown; the redaction is painted into the printed copy, not laid over it. More on what photo metadata shows: photos as court evidence.
General information, not legal advice. Courts decide what they accept and how; ask the court or a lawyer.
Open Court Copy Full exports free right now, nothing uploaded.