Photos as court evidence: what the metadata does and does not show
A phone photo carries more than the picture. Inside the file, the camera writes when it was taken by its own clock, often the time zone offset, the phone model, the software version and, if location was on, a GPS position. That is useful in a deposit dispute, a repair claim or a custody case, as long as you keep the original file and describe the metadata for what it is: what the file records.
What a photo file records
- Capture time (EXIF
DateTimeOriginal): the date and time on the device's clock when the picture was taken. iPhones and most Android phones also store the UTC offset (OffsetTimeOriginal, for example-05:00); older cameras store no time zone at all, so the time is only as right as the camera clock was. - Device: the make and model (
Apple iPhone 13,Google Pixel 8), often the lens and the software or iOS version that wrote the file. - Place: latitude, longitude and often altitude, if location services were on for the camera. On an iPhone that is Settings → Privacy & Security → Location Services → Camera.
- Orientation: a phone held upright usually saves the picture sideways with a tag saying "rotate 90° to view". Viewers apply it; so does Court Copy, and it says so on the page.
What it does not show
- Metadata can be wrong (a camera whose clock was never set) and it can be edited with free tools in seconds. A capture time in the file is what the file says, not proof by itself of when the picture was taken.
- The file date you see in Windows Explorer or Finder is when that copy was saved to the computer, not when the photo was taken. Copying, downloading or unzipping changes it.
- A screenshot usually has no capture time inside it at all. See screenshots of texts for court.
In most courts a photo is introduced by someone who can say it fairly shows what it shows (the person who took it, or someone who saw the scene). The metadata backs that up; it does not replace it. Ask the court's self-help centre or a lawyer what your court expects.
Keep the original file
Many ways of moving a photo strip its metadata or replace the file with a smaller copy. Text messages, WhatsApp, Messenger, Facebook, Instagram and most social apps send a re-compressed copy without the EXIF data. Ways that keep the original:
- iPhone to a Windows PC: connect with a cable and import with the Windows Photos app. To get the original HEIC files rather than converted JPEGs, set iPhone Settings → Apps → Photos → Transfer to Mac or PC to Keep Originals. The converted JPEGs keep the capture time and device too.
- iPhone to a Mac: AirDrop, or in the Photos app File → Export → Export Unmodified Original. In the iPhone share sheet, tap Options and turn on All Photos Data before saving to Files or AirDropping.
- Android: copy the files from
DCIM/Cameraover USB, or download them from Google Photos (Download keeps the original file). A Google Takeout.zipworks as it is: Court Copy skips the.jsonfiles Takeout puts next to each photo. - Email works if the phone sends the Actual Size picture.
Print them as numbered exhibits
Court Copy takes a folder, a .zip or loose photos (JPEG, PNG, WebP; HEIC in Safari) and scanned
PDFs, and makes one exhibit PDF in your browser; nothing is uploaded. It puts the files in capture-time order (you can drag them), then:
- a cover page listing every exhibit with its SHA-256 and the page it starts on;
- one page per photo, scaled to fit and never cropped, with the file name, size and SHA-256 of the original file, the pixel size, and the capture time, device, software and GPS position worded as "the file records…", or "no capture time is stored in the file" when there is none;
- an optional caption per photo, page stamps (PX000001…) for exhibit numbering, Exhibit 1, 2, 3 or A, B, C;
- redaction boxes that are painted into the printed copy, so the hidden pixels are not in the PDF (the hash stays the hash of the untouched original, and the cover says so);
- a CSV of the exhibit list: file, hash, capture time, device, GPS, pixel size and page range.
The SHA-256 lets anyone with the original file check it is the same file: on Windows certutil -hashfile IMG_0412.jpg SHA256,
on a Mac shasum -a 256 IMG_0412.jpg. Keep the originals unchanged in a folder you do not edit; if the other side asks for them,
the hashes on your exhibits match.
Do not want a home address on the page? Untick Print GPS places: positions are left out and the cover says so. The pictures in the PDF are re-drawn copies, so the original files' metadata is not hidden inside the PDF either.
Related
- Screenshots of texts for court: when to use the phone backup instead
- Scanned letters and documents as exhibits
General information, not legal advice. Rules on evidence differ between courts and countries.
Open Court Copy Full exports free right now, nothing uploaded.