Why NIH withdraws applications for formatting, and how to check yours in 30 seconds
NIH reads every attachment against a short list of hard rules before any reviewer sees it. Break one and the application can be withdrawn without review: months of work, gone for a margin or a font.
“Applications that include PDF attachments that do not conform to the minimum requirements listed above may be withdrawn from consideration.” NIH, Format Attachments
“Failure to follow these requirements may lead to application errors upon submission or withdrawal of your application from funding consideration.” NIH, Format Attachments
The rules that catch people
- Over the page limit. The Research Strategy is 12 pages for an R01 and 6 for an R21 or R03 (all limits). Figures count. NIH's system checks many limits automatically, but its staff check the rest by hand after submission.
- Type that is too dense. 11 pt is the minimum size, but the text must also stay at or under 15 characters per inch and 6 lines per inch. Times New Roman and Calibri at 11 pt are over 15 characters per inch on typical prose (measured), and tightening line spacing to squeeze in one more paragraph breaks the 6 lines per inch.
- Something in the margin. Half an inch on every side of every page, and "no applicant-supplied information can appear in the margins": a figure that bleeds to the edge, a header, a footer.
- Your own headers, footers and page numbers. NIH adds them when it assembles the application.
- The PDF itself. A password or security setting, form fields that were never flattened, sticky notes, a file name over 50 characters or with an "&".
- The converter shrank your font. NIH warns that "some PDF conversion software reduces font size": an 11 pt Word document can come out at 10.8 pt. Check the PDF, not the Word file.
Check yours in 30 seconds
- Open Grant Preflight and pick NIH, the application type, the attachment and your activity code (R01, R21…). If your NOFO sets a different page limit, type it in.
- Drop the PDF you will attach. It is read in your browser and never uploaded.
- Read the red items first. Each one shows what was measured, the rule, NIH's own words and the pages to look at, with the margin drawn on a picture of the page.
It measures what NIH measures: the body font size and anything smaller, characters per inch on every full line, the spacing between lines, every margin on every page, the page count against the limit for your attachment and activity code, and the PDF settings. It cannot read your NOFO's special instructions, judge whether a figure is legible, or promise NIH's staff will agree: treat it as a second pair of eyes, not a clearance.
Applying to NSF instead?
NSF's rules are different: named fonts only (Arial, Courier New or Palatino Linotype at 10 pt or more; Times New Roman or Computer Modern at 11 pt or more), 1-inch margins, 6 lines per inch, a 15-page Project Description with "Broader Impacts" as its own heading, and no URLs. NSF's rules, quoted.
“Conformance to the 15-page limit will be strictly enforced and may not be exceeded unless a deviation has been specifically authorized.” NSF PAPPG 24-1
About this tool, privacy and licences
Grant Preflight is a free tool by Tomorrowish. Not an official compliance check and not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by NIH, NSF, DOE, NASA, USDA, NEH, the European Commission, UKRI or any agency; agency names are used only to say whose published rules are quoted. Your notice of funding opportunity (NOFO) or program solicitation can change any limit here, and the agency's own review decides. It checks layout only: it never edits, writes or rewrites your work.
Privacy: your PDF or Word file is read inside this browser tab and never uploaded; the check page makes no requests to any other site (its security policy allows only tomorrowish.dev itself). The site is hosted on Cloudflare, which counts page views with Cloudflare Web Analytics (no cookies) on the rule and guide pages; on the check page its security policy blocks even that. The rule and guide pages add one to an anonymous view counter on Tomorrowish's own small server (programfold.tomorrowish.dev): which page was opened, nothing else. Your last funder and attachment choice stays in this browser. Contact: hello@tomorrowish.dev. Privacy details · Licences.