Tomorrowish

How to renumber exhibits without leaving stale references

A new exhibit goes in at 3 the night before filing. Now old 3 is 4, old 4 is 5, and every "Exhibit 4" in the brief might mean either one.

Why find-and-replace makes it worse

Replacing "Exhibit 3" with "Exhibit 4" and then "Exhibit 4" with "Exhibit 5" turns the first batch into 5 as well. Working from the highest number down avoids that chain, but only if nothing in the document was updated by hand already, and it still misses Exhibits 3-5, Exhs. 3 and 4, Exhibit No. 3, sub-parts like Exh. 3(a), and a range that stops being a run once the numbers move.

The old-or-new trap

After an insert, nearly every number is two things at once: an old exhibit and somebody else's new number. "Exhibit 5" in a half-updated draft could be old 5 (now 6) or new 5 (formerly 4). Nothing in the sentence tells you which; only the person who edited it knows. A checker should say so instead of guessing, and change only the references that can mean one thing.

A checklist that holds up

  1. Write the map down before touching the document. One line per change, old → new, with removed exhibits marked (OMIT 9). Paste two columns straight from the exhibit index spreadsheet if you keep one.
  2. Decide which numbering the draft is in. Untouched (all old), already renumbered (hunting leftovers), or mixed. If you do not know, it is mixed.
  3. Check every reference against the map, including footnotes, the table of contents, the exhibit list, the declaration that authenticates them, and the proposed order. The Exhibit Reference Checker does this in your browser and lists what to change, what is ambiguous, and what points at a removed exhibit.
  4. Resolve the ambiguous ones by reading the sentence. The quote, date or page cited usually shows which document is meant.
  5. Fix ranges by hand when they break. Exhibits 6-8 becoming 7, 9 and 10 has to be written as a list.
  6. Re-check the finished draft in "new numbering" mode. Every reference should come back "already new"; anything else is a leftover.
  7. Match the stickers. Last, compare the exhibit tabs or slip sheets with the final index, since the brief can be right and the binder wrong.

In Word next time

If you control the template, number exhibits with a SEQ field and refer to them with cross-references (Insert → Cross-reference), then update fields (Ctrl+A, F9) after moving one. That only helps for references made as fields; text typed or pasted from another draft stays plain, which is where a checker earns its keep.

This guide page counts views anonymously (page name only); the checker itself makes no requests at all. General drafting tips, not legal advice. Your court's rules on exhibit numbering and labelling come first.

Check a document now